PoC with European Culture
People tend to assume representation doesn’t “count” unless the person in question displays overt markers of the culture in the geographic region associated with that skin tone.
This is false.
PoC vikings existed, or, at least, could plausibly exist. Vikings had fairly extensive trade with North Africa, and were pretty socially open from what we’ve been able to recover. So historically, you’re not incorrect that this situation is something that very well could have happened.
But beyond that, the concept that skin tones relate to what culture people should display helps perpetuate xenophobia.
PoC can hold any culture they want, even if they don’t “look the part.” Yes, the traditional mould of a Viking is white— but so what? Why do they have to be white? Why does anyone from Europe have to be white?
Rome was a multicultural empire and brought people from all reaches of Africa and Asia Minor to Europe, and they stayed; these people formed communities that are just as European as white people. Immigration happened (such as Japanese people who came to Spain in the 1600s, who hold the last name Japón as markers they were descendants of original immigrants). Migration happened. Some of these cultures stayed independent, while others blended in. Curry, for example, is one of the most popular foods in the UK.
Ambiguously Brown comes from primarily not having any distinctly identifying features that make a person a specific ethnicity. So if somebody is described in a way you can tell they would be considered Arab, or Black, or Indigenous, it’s not ambiguously brown (in my opinion— others are allowed to disagree).
Now, if you wanted to be sure to avoid it, have some of them with scraps of tradition that come from immigration various generations ago. It doesn’t have to be overt, but little markers would show “this people is multicultural and has a lot of immigration.”
At the same time, it’s not necessary. It just shows that immigration happens. There’s no consensus on whether or not this is preferred. And it doesn’t have to be every character with a certain skin tone. Showing individual nuances is purely about immigration.
But in terms of general principle, not everyone from Europe can be or even should be white. It’s a multicultural place and has been since the dawn of time; no sense in shying away from that.
~ Mod Lesya