I think some people pick the marginalizations of their characters based on the dictates of the plot. Stories where a character’s marginalizations are not the main focus of the plot sometimes get accused of having them deviate from the assumed whiteness/straightness/etc. just for diversity points. But I just figured out why they think this way.
They’re using their plots to decide the characters’ identities.
For example, if they want to write about familial oppression, they make their protagonist a member of a group they associate with strict parents and conservative customs It doesn’t occur to them that a story about an overbearing father doesn’t need a stereotypical ethnic group to back it up. So when they see someone writing cheerful hijabis or who are totally chill about gayness and have good relationships with their parents or whatever, they’re like “wait, this hijabi woman is happy. If she’s happy, then why did you need to make her Muslim? YOU MUST BE DOING IT FOR DIVERSITY POINTS.”



sushinfood
mirandaadria
yourfavouritedoll